Gents (and any ladies interested, of course!)
Incidentally, I hear and understand many of the expert comments regarding bearing materials, use of Babbit, etc. and regarding oils and viscosity.
Thanks for countering my arguments, and I am sure we are all "correct" in some way or another, but having worked alongside the bearing engineer, and the oil engineer and chemist, it is their sole job upon which they summarise all the thousands of hours of testing, varying conditions of use of each engine application, etc. etc... and I defy any individual to do a better job at recommending the best oils for the various conditions as mentioned in service manuals. But if their expertise fails in some way for your application then you have probably got a good alternative - or you would not be recommending it. All I can say is without loads of details I cannot disagree with anything you are posting, but I stick to my earlier recommendations.

K2