Windows shopping for 3-D printer.

Home Model Engine Machinist Forum

Help Support Home Model Engine Machinist Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Tin,

What aonemarine said.......

I'm not familiar with the soliddoodle specifically. but with any 3D printer there are a couple things you need to do before you start printing - both should be covered in your printer instructions:

The first is leveling the build plate so that the gap to the nozzle is the same at all locations on the plate. You can do it with feeler gauges, or rig a dial indicator mount on the print head. It's the 3D printer equivalent of tramming a milling machine.

The second is to set the print head to build plate minimum gap.

Once these are done you're ready to print a calibration object and enter any adjustments following the directions for your specific printer.

Now it's time to print the fun stuff!

The first two steps don't take but a few minutes, and the 3rd is dependent on how long the calibration print takes.
 
I have the SOlidoodle4 and think it is an excellent machine. I like the way it is buuit around a metal box frame instead of the jungle jim look of threaded rod. I also like the full enclosed box since temperature stability is helpful for print. I wonder how they are doing that, since Stratsys holds a patent on an enclosed space, as dumb as that sounds.

My machine arrive just a couple days before cabin fever, and now I am in Detroit for NAMES, so I have not really had much time with it- I have printed a couple things and I am happy with the surface finish- they still show some ribbing but I think they can be filled or smothed to make investment patterns.

I like the comment that this is still 'toddler stage' It will develop over time, deciding just when to jump in is hard.
I am to old to wait very long.
 
Ron,

If you haven't already, check out the thingiverse.com site. There's some pretty interesting stuff there.

What print resolution are you using? The finer the resolution you use, the better the surface smoothness - the trade off is that it takes longer to print.

I'm in the early stages of designing a couple of scale model steam turbines. My plan is to make the patterns for the casings using the 3D printer and then sand cast them.
 
I like the comment that this is still 'toddler stage' It will develop over time, deciding just when to jump in is hard.
I am to old to wait very long.

Yep knowing when to jump where to jump ect.

I guess in a perfect world I would want to buy one learn how it works and build a better one.

and to buy a cheap one and throw a bunch of money in ? Makes more sense to get something decent.

I expect to tinker but at this point I think I want something that can make parts not something that is another project.


Eventbot.A possibility but need to dig to get the plan the info is there is a google sketup file . I can download a trial version of cubify design and make drawings of the individual parts from the stl files.

So do I buy one build one or both??


The casting thing is certainly a possible application . Years ago i set up a sandbox casting bench and built a couple flasks. I have a small gas forge I have used for smithing. . Weld up a couple small pipe crucibles and I can pour aluminum. And the printer can print patterns.

Thank you all for the input, and encouragement.
Tin
 
More pondering and drooling . I am looking at the solid doodle 2G and the asterid hb middle grade. unit. The more I look at the asterid the more I like it.


They both have things I like and things to be improved upon. the question I am asking my self is what can I easily fix. and what would I have to live with.

the biggest downside of the sd is only one lead screw to lift the table so the table is only supported in the back. and the 6x6 build envelope is smaller than the other one.

The other question I ask is how big a print envelope do I need. 6X6 x6 would probably work but 8 x 8 x 8 gives more flexibility.
just for fun I ran some numbers. A 1 kilo 2.2 lb spool of ABS will print a cube just under 4". so if and it would never happen it would take 8 spools for a 8" solid cube and @ $30 a spool well you get the Idea.
But I know I can always print smaller. and since the printer stretcher has not been invented yet a little bigger is likely better.


Interesting seems like many of the hobby level 3-d printers are made with 3-D printed parts so if one starts by making spare parts there is no need to purchase them.

I have also noticed there is a big difference in the price of spare parts the spares list for the asterid is not long but the prices are very reasonable.

The
Asterid 1000HB 3D Printer definitely has room to improve tinker with. the good side is it is ready to print out of the box . 30 day money back guarantee. But the fixes are well fixable. it is an open design but not difficult to add cover panels . I would prefer easy access to the power supply and the computer controller board Likely not hard to move outside the box. or I could add a cover. The wires are out in the open but easily dressed up.

I have also been reading about the differences between ABS and PLA.


I know I am thinking out loud here. I am hoping my pondering , research and posting here helps others as well as my own decision making.

Tin
 
Tin, I had thought about building my own printer. I sources out parts and prices, ordered a few bits and pieces, then just bought one as a kit instead. It to me over 30 hours to assemble my rostock, and a few weeks of learning the machine before I could print with the best of them. I just upgraded the stock hot end I had Ben using for the past 7 months to a new all metal hot end so I can try printing with nylon. It's taking some playing to get the new hot end figured out for the .1 mm layer height prints that I want for investment casting. If the nozzle plugs up one more time I'm going to pull someone's hair out!! Yep 3d printing in a nut shell... If your in the area sometime and want to stop by to bs about 3 d printing and see my printer just let me know when. Maybe Matt, my partner in crime will have time for us to drop in on him as well to see his printers, he has much more knowledge than I do when it comes to them. He has a makerbot replicator, an ultimaker,a robo3d, and a deltamaker. Maybe even one or two more I dont know of LOL.
 
I am still pondering researching.
Trying to tuck some money aside.

I like the looks of the eventorbot. like many it is open source.
the info is there but much detail to be extracted.
Parts to be sourced etc.
Sain Smart has lots of package options for all the controls from about $ 90 for a basic controller to a full package for $300 with a smart controller cables steppers limit switches etc.

http://www.sainsmart.com/ramps-1-4-a4988-mega2560-r3-lcd-12864-3d-printer-controller-kit-for-reprap.html
then I need linear bearings guide rod the extrude parts etc.
linear bearing can run from about a dollar a piece to $30 each and I could pay close to $80 for a power supply. or find one for $30
SO one needs to do a lot research just to buy right.

It seems like the original project leader and kick starter project is going nowhere no activity for about a year.

I am still looking hard at the plastic scribbler. $499- about 699 but is comes assembled and more or less plug and play . choices choices.
Tin
 
Tin, might be more than you want to spend, but I liked this one
http://www.fabbaloo.com/blog/2014/4/19/the-mankati-fullscale-xt-3d-printer

I would have an email with contact details for the manufacturer. From memory the quote I got a few months ago was about USD $1800 delivered to Australia and has a big build envelope.

It seems a very well built and is a dual filament machine. This lets you use 2 different materials and you can buy a tank that disolves one of them which allows you to build supports for much more complex shapes by adding support structures that are disolved.
 
Like you I've developed an interest in these machines but have yet to secure the funds and honestly I'm in need of other tools. So I've been collecting stuff to eventually just make one of my own design. Well one built out of the collection of parts I'm building up. Mechanically the machines are very simple so with access to machine shop equipment you can easily build something out of your imagination.


There have been a fair amount of 3-d printers at some of the ME shows. And I have a friend that has done some amazing things w 3d printer. . He is a retired college instructor. I need to stop in I drive by his house daily. I probably need to ask more questions.



A 3-D printer is a tool. what you can do with it is only limited by imagination and the time and effort used to learn how to use it. what is the use of a mill or lathe in a hobby shop??
Actually that is mentioned in the context of anything CNC related. People just don't understand the flexibility of CNC in general. More interesting is the fact that 3D printing via methods other than extrusion are becoming very affordable and accessible. Patents running out help this by making these machines more widely available.
IMHO 3-D printing is in the toddler stage. Past infancy but still in development.
At our end of the market that is certainly the case. At the other end of the market you have NASA printing rocket parts in metals. There is an incredible range of capabilities here.
Apparently these things will make toys candy chocolate wax patterns etc.

If a 3-D printer can make parts to build a 3-d printer there is potential.

A lathe is touted for self replicating.



I am trying to decide if a 3-D printer is right for me. And which one .



Tin


Well honestly you probably won't know until you have had the machine for awhile. I've had a strong desire for a CNC router for some time too, it can be frustrating because you can't have both. Well at least not without blowing your budget.

As far as which one, the one you design and build yourself will likely be the most cost effective. It isn't impossible and can allow you to leverage stuff laying around. One thing to keep in mind is that you are not building a machine to cut anything (metal, plastic wood) thus there is no need for lots of mass. The axis also move relatively fast so mass control is important in that regard. This is also why uncommon building materials can often be used in the machines, Baltic birch ply for example is plenty stiff enough for a cheap 3D printer. Further the Reprap folks use plastic where no self respecting machine tool builder would have ten years ago. Keep in mind the application and alternatives begin to look far more feasible.

There is a lot of appeal to kits but for most people in these forums they are awfully expensive considering we already have most of the machining capability required. You look at many of the kits and it is like what is here that cost so much. So maybe a look at your scrap heap might inspire you to see some of that stuff as a printer. Most(many) of these machines are belt driven so a good portion of your linear motion hardware is pretty simple. In the end there are so many designs out there already that you have plenty of ideas to draw from.

Just an idea here, I just hate spending lots of money for very little. If DIY machine tools isn't your thing I can understand, but it is worth a thought. You might be surprised to find what you already have laying around that could go to a 3D printer.


Sent from my iPad using Model Engines
 
still pondering and saving money.
Still tying to decide if I scratch build or buy a pre built.
I need to also decid if if I need 1 head or two. I know the two headed monster allows for disolvable support.
 
Recall I got a Solidoodle4 Just before I left for Cabin Fever, then I had both knees replaced in June, so I am just back to trying this thing out. My nerd grandson arrived a few days ago, about the time we discovered some broken plastic pats in the patio table my wife uses. Well, Solidoodle to the rescue. We measured, drew and printed 4 end caps that go on the metal legs to protect the glass top. They went together perfectly and the table is now on the deck and my wife is happy, at least briefly :)

So, my first useful printed part. I have no idea how long they will last, the originals were killed by the sun UV. But they only took about an hour to print, so I guess when these fail we can just print more.
 
still pondering and saving money.
Still tying to decide if I scratch build or buy a pre built.
I need to also decid if if I need 1 head or two. I know the two headed monster allows for disolvable support.

Tin, I have not been game enough to put a 3D printer on my list of thing for the workshop.......

I would go for the two filament one. In addition to supports, this would let you insert say white lettering into a black button for a machine or electronic device just like they do on quality keyboards....You'll think of other similar things you could do with 2 colours
 
Hmm another Interesting Idea. I think I would have to build this one.
do not think commercially available. It is a full sized 3 - d portable printer that folds into a briefcase sized case and fit into the overhead compartment on commercial aircraft not that I fly much. But would make it easy to take to Model engineering shows.


So has anyone ever heard of the Ben Heck Show?? from what I have seen could easily be called the Ben Hack show. sponsored by element 14 as an infomercial series for electron heads.

watch the video and tell me what you think could be doable and great for us folk with limited shop space. Store in a closet , set up on a table print and store when done. But I see no place for tool storage but not to fear as Ben Heck has designed and built a portable tool bench box for electronics work. And one still needs things like rolls of ABS or PLA to feed this tiny machine. so the briefcase turns into 3 or four briefcase sized boxes when all is said and done. Still More portable than an 18" cube just for the printer.
Another Idea to ponder.


[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xJndXebTG9I[/ame]
Tin
 
Tin, this is an Interesting video as it shows how simple they are to make (if you have the tools like we do). I think I have enough steppers here that I scrounged a while ago, and a box of Arduinos, just have to sort out the base plate and extruder... maybe I should give it a go...
 
I got a B9 Creator, which is much more pricey (hello used machines on their forum!). Its a resin based machine and I liked that it was all open source. If you really wanted to (and others have, one made an MDF version), you can download all the files and make one. Still more expensive getting the projector and all, but boy it makes cool parts. Also it uses an investment casting compatible resin that burns out nicely. Here are a few recent casts I did including a few key chains of our little dog for the wife's birthday!

Takes a lot of tinkering and is not as useful for non casting related parts, but it's fun to have!

Copy of 20140620_124649.jpg


Copy of 20140620_084807.jpg


Copy of 20140620_084924.jpg


IMG_1316.JPG
 
just have to sort out the base plate and extruder... maybe I should give it a go...

the heated borosilicate glass base you pretty much have to buy . The Hot bed and glass plate are about $20 each.

The extruder can be purchased or you can make one not real complicated. a stepper a pinch roller with spring you need a heater block with heater and thermosistor and you need to make or buy a nozzle.

https://www.buildyourcnc.com/item/3D-Printer-Component-extruder
Tin
 
the heated borosilicate glass base you pretty much have to buy . The Hot bed and glass plate are about $20 each.

The extruder can be purchased or you can make one not real complicated. a stepper a pinch roller with spring you need a heater block with heater and thermosistor and you need to make or buy a nozzle.

https://www.buildyourcnc.com/item/3D-Printer-Component-extruder
Tin

Thanks Tin.

I found them on eBay locally at about the price you said. Maximium size seemed to be 200x200mm (8x8").

I've got 2 x NEMA 17's (different sizes) and 1 x NEMA 23, a Gecko GX240 stepper driver and a few Arduino UNO controllers here. Repetier firmware seems to be the go. As you said, the extruders seem to be fairly simple to make.

So I am some steppers and a couple of stepper drivers short.

I know we like to be precise on this forum. Would there be any benefit in using ballscrews and linear rails on the axes? They are not that expensive and I can machine the ball screw ends. Machining the end of the ball screws should be a cinch if I had to. I did see one on Youtube made this way.
 
This printer http://www.thingiverse.com/search/page:1?q=aluminatus&sa= is pretty nice, but unfortunately the company who built it is now defunct. It uses screws for all axis instead of belts and people have been mounting dremels to them to do a bit of engraving and extremely light milling. Have a look and tell me what you guys think...
 
One option I have considered is a kit from sainsmart. IIRC they are out of hong kong possibly mainland china.
Free shipping to USA and Australia.

Looks like the same electronics that one would find in a plastic scribbler for about $250. yes still need to build the frame buy belts pulleys guide rod linear bearings etc. power supply etc. but an option. These guys have lots options from a single board to an entire electrons package.


Ramps 1.4 Mega 2560 3-d printer kit w steppers

IMHO a gecko drive is way overkill for a printer.

the ramps board has a place for 6 drivers keep in mind a 3-d printer board needs to control two heaters as well as 6 motors.
Just the controller a mega 2560 ramps 1.4 and 5 plug in drivers will run about $60.
Ramps contoler kit

01.JPG


ramps.jpg


My main hesitation of buying such a kit besides the time to engineer and assemble is the cost of all the extra parts. Most the complete kits I have seen are not impressive and more money than a solid doodle.

Tin
 

Latest posts

Back
Top