Yes I use a Smoothstepper.
RE noise, my servos are MUCH quieter than my steppers in every regime but dead stop, and even then they're quiet just not quieter. Ron, I do wonder about the tuning if yours were so noisy.
Be that as it may, as I said above, I'd lean towards steppers for your mill. For a larger mill, I don't regret the servos though. Just be ready for the increased complexity involved if you choose that path.
Getting back to the Smoothstepper, I like it, BUT...
Not all Mach3 features work for it yet. There are two in particular that I find annoying to be without:
- There is no backlash compensation. But wait, you say, with good ballscrews you have no backlash! Not true. You just have a lot less, and backlash comp can still improve your machine's performance. If you're not running ballscrews with preload nuts you will likely really miss the backlash comp.
- There is no feedrate override. I really like FRO. For example, my programs often cut air for a little while to allow for variation in the initial rough sawn workpiece. With FRO I can crank my feed way up and get done cutting air sooner. I often restart programs, and may not know exactly where I need to run to (i.e. which line of code). I can crank FRO and get done cutting air sooner. Lastly, the feedrate can vary surprisingly much based on what the endmill is doing. Most CAM software doesn't take this into account unless you have an expensive high speed machining option. Having started out a manual machinist, your eyes and ears can do a pretty good job. You can nurse that FRO and get done cutting your part sooner, or avert a problem of too fast a feed without having to stop the program and modify it if you have FRO.
These features are supposed to be coming, but the guy who invented Smoothstepper is not very responsive or communicative. You can go weeks on his forum without him saying anything. I worry sometimes about orphaned products if the guy's priorities in life change. I have had this happen to me twice now with CNC electronics and it is really painful to have spent the time and money only to discover you have to rip it back out or live with the limitations because the device is orphaned.
I am not saying this will happen with Smoothstepper, and I love mine, but it is something to think about. I don't think you want to be too far off the beaten path with Mach3.
Best,
BW