

09122011, 05:35 PM

#1

Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 183
Liked 10 Times on 10 Posts

How to learn some basic science/ mechanics?
Just back from holiday where I read 'The engines of our ingenuity' by John Lienhard and 'Victorian engineering' by L T C Rolt
in the 1st book:
'the modern propeller bladed windmill is 3 or 4 times more efficient than the advanced 18th century mills and 40 times more powerful'
I'm thinking ummm… there's another factor of 10 in there somewhere but what is it?
in the 2nd book:
re water wheels: 'the buckets or floats on a water wheel have to revolve at half the speed of the water impinging on them''
I'm thinking ummm…how does that go then?
That’s a couple of examples. I can go find the answers to those , but generally there's a feeling I don’t know enough fundamental science / mechanics.
I've looked up concepts like force, power, work in books & seen formulae but not really got a feel for it.
For example if you showed me 2 random projects of the month & asked which was more efficient / powerful I'd probably have to guess.
Also when I learned electricity I learned using the 'water pipe' example. Ok to a point but I want a deeper understanding.
This ring any bells with anyone in terms of learning the fundamentals? I could sign up for evening classes for a year or so, but I'm hoping to find a quicker way. Anyone got any suggestions / experiences for learning the basics?
Mike



09122011, 05:54 PM

#2

Project of the Month Winner!!!
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 1,179
Liked 61 Times on 58 Posts

Re: How to learn some basic science/ mechanics?



09122011, 06:09 PM

#3

Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: LA, CA, USA
Posts: 3,039
Liked 138 Times on 258 Posts Likes Given: 2

Re: How to learn some basic science/ mechanics?
Let's not confuse "knowing enough" with "getting a feel for". The former is an academic pursuit and the latter is mostly a matter of experience. Most experience isn't all that useful unless you have the academic framework in place so that you can relate the experience to its underlying principles.
Your best bet, of course, is to take some college level courses in physics and mathematics. The physics will give you the framework and the math is necessary to really understand the physics.
If you wish to study on your own, a good introductory physics text is "University Physics" by Sears and Zemansky. Do the problems  you'll never learn physics if you don't do the problems. (The recommended book has the answers to the oddnumbered problems in the back.)
You'll need some proficiency in analytic geometry, vector calculus, and differential and integral calculus. Get "Calculus and Analytic Geometry" by Thomas, which also has answers to some of the problems in the back.
__________________
Regards, Marv
Home Shop Freeware
http://www.myvirtualnetwork.com/mklotz



09122011, 07:27 PM

#4

Guest

Re: How to learn some basic science/ mechanics?
Mike
I struggled in a big way with math in school, and the reason was that math teachers don't teach applied math, but just pure theory.
Pure math theory without any connection to the real world has no meaning to me.
I learned electricity using the water flowing in pipes analogy.
If you are very lucky, you can find that rare individual who is good at both math and explaining how to apply math to practical everyday problems.
When I was in school, we had to take an EIT (engineering in training, now called engineering fundamentals) test, and this test covered a wide variety of topics across many branches of engineering, such and electrical, mechanical, thermodynamics, statics, dynamics, you name it.
I still have my EIT study guide because it has a summary of the major formulas used for each of these fields.
If you look at the forumulas used in engineering, they are pretty much the same for mechanical, electrical, thermodynamics, aerodynamics, etc., but just written in different ways, such as V=I*R and PV=MRT.
The formulas for any branch of engineering all have to adhere to the same constraints regarding the laws of physics, and the law of physics says there must always be a conservation of energy. Electrical equations are often used to model mechanical systems, since it all boils down to the flow of energy, and the electrical formulas can easily describe the flow of energy.
Think in terms of a black box, which may be an engine or motor of some type.
You have to input a certain amount of energy into this black box, and no matter what, you cannot get more energy back out of the box than you put in, and will always get less energy back out, since some mechanical energy will always be converted to heat energy via friction, etc.
Understanding a machine is like the expression used for understanding people, "follow the money", but instead use "follow the energy" and you will understand the machine.
Generally there are a few basic formulas that define each branch of engineering, and you really just need to understand those formulas. The formulas are basically the same, but just written using different variables, so they seem different, but they are really generally about the same.
Mathematics is basically a language, and if you can read the language, then you can understand a machine and how it will operate.
E=mC squared is a simple little formula, but the meaning behind it is that if you split an atom, you get two smaller particles, and a huge amount of energy released.
Bottom line is that matter contains a huge amount of energy.
Geometery defines planes and lines which are drawn on these planes.
Algebra defines the fundamentals of addition, subtraction, multiplication and division.
Algebra is very basic, and came from some farmer wanting to sell 10 bushels of corn, or figure out how to grow 100 bushels instead of 10, or sell 1/2 of his 10 bushels, etc.
Statics applies geometry to vector equations. Vectors are variables with have both a magnitude (force) and a direction.
If you can add up all the vectors in a truss bridge, you can find out where the forces are concentrating, and design the bridge to function safely.
Static equations are applied to things that are stationary and not moving.
Dynamics used vectors that are moving, such as an ice skater who controls their spinning speed by moving their arms closer or further away from their body.
Once you get into dynamics, you get into calculus.
Many of the old steam engine books from the 1,800's are full of calculus, and it was well understood in the 1,800's and before.
Calculus is a lot simplier than most people think, and basically deals with rates of change (such as the rate of change of velocity), and integration which is just addition.
The reason you need calculus to design a steam engine is because you have a situation where the piston starts with zero velocity, then accelerates (acceleration is just the rate of change of velocity) to some maximum value when the crank is near 90 degrees, and then begins to decelerate to a zero velocity at the end of the stroke.
If you plot out the acceleration, you can also figure out the maximum forces that are generated on the parts, and design the part and fastener accordingly.
Changing the velocity or direction of a mass always requires energy.
You transfer the energy from the burning fuel to the water, converting it to steam, then let the steam expand in the cylinder, transferring some energy to the piston, then store some of the energy in the flywheel. Other energy is lost due to friction of the parts that make contact, and some energy is wasted just accelerating and decelerating parts. Any unbalanced forces have are transmitted into the frame and then the base of the engine, and the base then has to absorb this energy.
A percentage of the energy from the burning fuel is converted into useful work (generally a pretty small percentage).
Math is like machining, if you use it a lot, you generally get better at it, and understand it better.
Engineering school is like math boot camp, where you are forced to learn the language of math and how to apply it.
Difficult at first, just like machining, and easier over time. Unlike machining, I can use an eraser on my equations if they are not correct.
There are some good fundamentals books out there.
Hope this helps.
Pat J



09122011, 07:34 PM

#5

Project of the Month Winner!!!
Join Date: Aug 2009
Posts: 930
Liked 32 Times on 51 Posts

Re: How to learn some basic science/ mechanics?
Just be glad that you can now use scientific calculators to speed up your math calculations. When I was in college, all we had were slide rules. The only calculators around then were "four bangers"  add, subtract, multiply and divide. Not even a square root function.
__________________
Dennis
Once you see the bandwagon, it's too late.



09122011, 07:45 PM

#6

Guest

Re: How to learn some basic science/ mechanics?
True story, when I started engineering in 1976, they had this giant slide rule hanging up in front of the classroom.
On the first day the instructor said "everybody needs to buy a GOOD slide rule".
I walked straight to the main office and withdrew from school.
Two years later, I signed up again, and this time the instructor said "everybody needs a GOOD calculator".
I thought to myself "now I can handle that", and I did.
Its not about how good you are at using a slide rule (or even a calculator).
It is about understanding and applying formulas efficiently.
A calculator is like going from hand washing clothes in a nearby stream to using a washing machine.
Pat J



09122011, 08:09 PM

#7

Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Detroit
Posts: 978
Liked 62 Times on 56 Posts Likes Given: 17

Re: How to learn some basic science/ mechanics?
While I remember the basic calculator taking the world by storm, it still only gives you an answer. The slide rule shows you the relationship getting to the answer.
One of the brightest guys I know has a habit of making slide rules out of napkins to explain concepts at Saturday morning breakfasts, taught me more then any plain answer does.
__________________
Jeff



09122011, 08:55 PM

#8

Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: LA, CA, USA
Posts: 3,039
Liked 138 Times on 258 Posts Likes Given: 2

Re: How to learn some basic science/ mechanics?
Pat
You wrote:
"If you look at the forumulas used in engineering, they are pretty much the same for mechanical, electrical, thermodynamics, aerodynamics, etc., but just written in different ways, such as V=I*R and PV=MRT."
I would really like you to show me how Ohm's Law and the Perfect Gas Law are "pretty much the same".
I have to take issue with some other things you said...
"Generally there are a few basic formulas that define each branch of engineering, and you really just need to understand those formulas. The formulas are basically the same, but just written using different variables, so they seem different, but they are really generally about the same."
Technical understanding is not about memorizing a bunch of formulae; it's about understanding the laws that govern nature and then using math to derive whatever expressions or results you need. No, I don't rederive the gas law every time I need it but the important thing is that I could derive it from Newton's laws applied to atoms presumed to behave like tiny billiard balls.
Trout,
You mentioned "not even a square root function".
I've been pondering this for a long time. Pick up any cheapo four banger  the kind that you can find at the dollar store or the kind your broker sends you for your birthday. Every damn one of them has a root key. My question is, "why?" The average American can't compute a 10% discount. He surely isn't doing any calculation involving roots. In fact, I'm sure he doesn't know what a root is. So why is that key on every four banger?
Don't tell me the function is already on the chip so they put it on the keyboard. These things are designed to be made as cheaply as possible. That extra key may represent 5% of the manufacturing cost. Leaving it off might lead to another penny profit in a world where a penny matters.
__________________
Regards, Marv
Home Shop Freeware
http://www.myvirtualnetwork.com/mklotz



09122011, 08:58 PM

#9

Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 183
Liked 10 Times on 10 Posts

Re: How to learn some basic science/ mechanics?
Just want to say thanks to you all for your replies. Thanks in advance for any additional info.
Hmem is a great place to hang out.
And so to bed...
Mike



09122011, 10:28 PM

#10

Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2008
Posts: 1,784
Liked 43 Times on 43 Posts

Re: How to learn some basic science/ mechanics?
I have to take exception to some comments regarding the usage of calculators. What would/do the youngsters in our midst do if they were not allowed the use of one or one is not at hand for them to use but a 'big bamboo' was? I think that I already know the answer to that one.... they would most likely google the answer or use their smart phone. Sure, it may be a great deal easier to use a calculator but then nobody ever said that life was going to be easy. To be so flippant indifferent about using a slide rule to me showsn a lack of ambition in a twisted kind of way.
BC1
Jim



Posting Rules

You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
HTML code is Off





